Grease vs Phase Change Thermal Interface Materials for Power Modules

Thermal grease and phase change materials both fill the gap between a power module and its heatsink, but they age differently. This guide compares process fit, reliability evidence and selection criteria for IGBT and SiC modules.

Every power module datasheet gives a junction-to-case figure, but heat still has to cross one more boundary before it reaches the heatsink. The thermal interface material (TIM) that fills the microscopic gaps there is easy to overlook, yet it can account for a large share of the total thermal path. At HIITIO, a Hangzhou-based manufacturer of IGBT, SiC and Si/SiC hybrid modules, mounting questions are a routine part of module integration. This article compares the two most common choices, thermal grease and phase change material (PCM), and explains how to choose between them.

Why the Interface Layer Deserves Attention

Junction-to-ambient thermal resistance is the sum of junction-to-case, case-to-heatsink and heatsink-to-ambient terms. The middle term depends on the TIM, the flatness and roughness of both surfaces, and the mounting pressure.

HIITIO datasheets show how large it can be. The HCS06FH120E2C1 SiC MOSFET module datasheet lists Rth(j-c) of 0.10 K/W and a grease contact resistance Rth(c-f) of 0.12 K/W, assuming 2.8 W/mK grease at 50 µm. Under those assumptions the interface contributes more than half of the junction-to-heatsink path (0.12 of 0.22 K/W). The HCG450FL065K1E1 datasheet, covering a 650 V / 450 A three-level NPC module with a copper baseplate, shows a similar pattern.

Table 1. Interface contribution in HIITIO datasheet examples (grease, λ = 2.8 W/mK)

Module / deviceRth(j-c) (K/W)Interface contribution (K/W)Stated basis
HCG450FL065K1E1, outer IGBT (Q1, Q4)0.160.08Rth(j-h) 0.24 minus Rth(j-c)
HCG450FL065K1E1, inner IGBT (Q2, Q3)0.180.10Rth(j-h) 0.28 minus Rth(j-c)
HCG450FL065K1E1, neutral-point diode (D5, D6)0.190.10Rth(j-h) 0.29 minus Rth(j-c)
HCG450FL065K1E1, inverse diode (D1–D4)0.320.09Rth(j-h) 0.41 minus Rth(j-c)
HCS06FH120E2C1, SiC MOSFET0.100.12Rth(c-f) listed; 50 µm grease assumed

HCG450FL065K1E1 interface values are our subtraction of two published figures. Both datasheets assume grease and do not predict PCM performance.

Thermal Grease: Strengths and Failure Modes

Thermal grease is a filled, non-curing paste that flows into surface roughness and can form a thin bond line. It remains the incumbent choice in many designs.

Where it works well

  • Controllable layer. Stencil or screen printing gives a defined pattern. Infineon’s EconoPACK and EconoPIM application note documents stencil printing of standard grease alongside its own pre-applied TIM, which shows both routes are established practice.
  • Flexibility. The assembler chooses the compound, thickness and pattern to suit the heatsink.
  • Immediate wetting. The interface is filled as soon as the module is torqued down.

Where it can degrade

  • Pump-out. As the device powers up and down, the die and heat spreader move relative to each other and squeeze grease out of the gap, according to DesignSpark’s TIM comparison.
  • Dry-out. At elevated temperature, filler can separate from the polymer matrix, leaving a more resistive layer.
  • Process sensitivity. Vincotech notes that thermal resistance rises if the layer is either too thin or too thick, so printing accuracy matters.

Phase Change Materials: How They Differ

A PCM is a solid at room temperature and softens above a defined transition temperature, after which it behaves much like grease. Vincotech describes a silicone-free, thixotropic material with a 45 °C phase change temperature, applied in a uniform layer at the module factory. DesignSpark describes a typical range of 50–90 °C, so formulations clearly differ.

Potential advantages

  • Pre-applied layer. Vincotech states that the customer is spared the task of applying TIM, saving time and reducing application risk.
  • Repeatable thickness. A factory-applied layer removes one variable from the assembly line.
  • Simpler handling. Once solidified, the module can be handled like a conventional one, though the layer needs protection from contact until mounting.

Limitations

  • Wet-out depends on heat. The material must exceed its transition temperature before it fills the interface fully.
  • Not immune to squeeze-out. DesignSpark notes that paraffin-based PCMs can be fragile and may also migrate during thermal cycling.
  • Formulation-specific results. One product’s performance does not transfer to another.

Table 2. Side-by-side comparison

AttributeThermal greasePhase change material
State at room temperatureSoft pasteSolid layer
Typical applicationStencil or screen printing at assemblyPre-applied on module or heatsink
Interface wettingImmediateAfter reaching phase change temperature
Main ageing mechanismsPump-out, dry-outSqueeze-out in some formulations, fragility
Cycling evidenceReported more stable in power cycling (SUNY study)Reported better in thermal cycling (SUNY study); supplier data favourable in power cycling (Henkel)
Main process riskLayer thickness errorDamage to the pre-applied layer before mounting
Typical fitAssembler controls the TIM processVolume production, repeatable bond line

What the Cycling Evidence Says

Published results do not point to a single winner. A university comparison of TIM degradation found that PCMs performed better in thermal cycling, while grease was more stable in power cycling.

A supplier case study from Henkel points the other way. In its power module reliability example, active power cycling between −50 °C and 150 °C produced fatal results for two greases after 600 and 800 hours, while LOCTITE TCP 7000, rated at 3.0 W/mK, did not fail at 1,000 hours. The same page reports a thermal impedance of 0.062 for the PCM against 0.160 for grease, roughly 60% lower (units as published; check the source). This is supplier-reported data for one formulation and should be read that way.

The practical conclusion is that the result depends on the specific material, the module construction and the stress profile. Neither category can be assumed superior without testing.

How to Choose for Your Design

  1. Define the dominant stress. Frequent large load swings stress the interface differently from slow ambient cycling. Match qualification tests to the real mission profile.
  2. Consider production volume. Pre-applied PCM suits repeatable, high-volume lines. Grease suits flexible or low-volume assembly.
  3. Check surface flatness. The heatsink and baseplate condition affects both materials. Follow the mounting note for your package.
  4. Respect the datasheet. Mounting torque and surface requirements are package-specific. For example, the HCG450FL065K1E1 datasheet specifies M5 screws at 3.0–5.0 N·m.
  5. Measure in your assembly. Datasheet Rth values assume grease at a stated conductivity. A PCM will differ, so verify with your own thermal tests.

Where HIITIO Fits

HIITIO supplies IGBT modules, SiC modules, Si/SiC hybrid modules and high-voltage IGBT modules, with gate drive options in the IGBT & SiC driver range. Formats listed on the power module catalogue include 62mm, Econo Dual, Econo PIM, Easy and E6 packages. Examples include the 62mm 1200 V 200 A SiC module, the 62mm 1200 V 450 A IGBT module and the Econo PIM 3H 1700 V 150 A module. HIITIO states that its production includes 100% X-ray void inspection, which addresses voids inside the module; the TIM then governs the next boundary outside it.

Qualify the Interface with HIITIO

Choosing between grease and phase change material is only half the job; the module, heatsink and mounting process must be qualified together. HIITIO’s power module range covers IGBT, SiC and hybrid modules across 650 V to 6500 V, and datasheets for each part are available for download. If you are comparing TIM options for a specific package, send us your heatsink flatness, expected load cycling and target junction temperature. Our engineers can review the datasheet thermal data with you and discuss mounting guidance and customised module solutions for your application. Contact the HIITIO team through the product pages to request a datasheet, a quotation or a technical discussion.

FAQ

Is phase change material always better than thermal grease?

No. A university study found PCMs better in thermal cycling but grease more stable in power cycling, while a supplier case study reported the opposite for one PCM. Test your own assembly.

What is pump-out?

Pump-out is the gradual displacement of grease from the interface as the module and heatsink move relative to each other during power and temperature cycles. It raises interface resistance over time, as described by DesignSpark.

Can I use a datasheet Rth(j-h) value with a phase change material?

Not directly. HIITIO datasheet values assume grease at 2.8 W/mK, and the HCS06FH120E2C1 figure also assumes 50 µm. A PCM will differ, so measure it in your assembly.

How thick should the TIM layer be?

It depends on the module, surface flatness and material. Too thin or too thick raises resistance, so follow the mounting note for your package and verify thermal results on the finished assembly.

How Can We Help?

Get a Custom Power Module Solution

Tell us your project requirements, and our engineering team will provide tailored recommendations within 24 hours.

广告表单

Download Resources

Access datasheets and in-depth IGBT semiconductor insights to support your next project.

SEO弹窗表单

Powered by HIITIO – All right reserved.  Private Policy

Keep in Touch

Get key updates and IGBT insights before you go.

挽留表单

Talk to Our Product Experts

Contact Form